Opinion: E.T. Are You Out There?

If the cosmos is filled with alien life - then why haven't we heard from them? Photo Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle

If the cosmos is filled with alien life, then why haven’t we heard from them? Photo Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle

This article originally appeared on the website for The Planetary Society and is republished with permission.

You and your wife are on a two-hour trip late at night in separate cars, travelling through dense fog. You need to talk but you can’t see her. She’s out there somewhere. The only mode of communication with her is a CB with a hundred different channels and no idea which one she might be on. You both go through them one at a time, but the odds of each of you landing on the same frequency at the right moment are long indeed. …

That is just one of the many problems that SETI has had to deal with for over 50 years in their quest for contact with an extraterrestrial civilization. Science tells us that the same elements and processes that made us and our world are at work throughout the galaxy. The Kepler telescope is discovering new planets all the time. Out of the roughly

The Kepler Space Telescope is finding more and more planets that could have suitable habitats for life. Image Credit: NASA

The Kepler Space Telescope is finding more and more planets that could have suitable habitats for life. Image Credit: NASA

200 billion stars in our galaxy, there may be a billion Earth-type planets.

That’s potential for a lot of life out there.

But for a single exception, the SETI telescopes have heard nothing.

That exception occurred at Ohio State University on August 15, 1977. Jerry Ehman was using the university’s radio telescope Big Ear to look for ET’s calling card. In going over the data he discovered a signal that stood out very distinctly from the background radio noise and looked exactly like what they expected an extraterrestrial signal might look like. Ehman was so excited he wrote “WOW!” in the margin next to the startling series of numbers and letters. Only problem was that after 72 seconds the signal never repeated itself … ever. And that by SETI’s definition still classifies it as an unknown to this day. Interestingly enough, years later we sent out a radio signal using the powerful Arecibo Telescope in Puerto Rico. And we only sent it once. No repeat. Now if any alien civilization were to someday pick it up and used the same criteria we use, they would probably come to a similar conclusion.

We probably don’t exist either.

In 1961, Frank Drake came up with an equation that attempts to calculate how many extraterrestrial civilizations might be out there. The equation uses a set of seven definitions from the rate of star formation to the length of time a civilization might last. The number he came up with was 10,000. Now, of course, that’s purely a guess, but if he’s right, why haven’t we seen or heard any evidence of them? There should be all kinds of chatter out there.

In the summer of 1950, Italian physicist Enrico Fermi was having lunch with Edward Teller of all people. The discussion turned to the possible existence of aliens, and Fermi came up with what has long been known as “The Fermi Paradox.”

Fermi ‘s basic premise was this: 1. The Milky Way is probably teeming with planetary candidates that could harbor intelligent life. 2. Most of the 200 billion stars out there are considerably older than our Sun. 3. You’d have to assume there are many intelligent civilizations far more advanced than ours, maybe millions of years older or more. 4. Even just one of those civilizations would have had more than ample time to colonize most of our galaxy. 5. We certainly would have seen evidence of their existence by now. 6. So, where are they?

What about UFOs? Might they be an answer to Fermi’s Paradox? Maybe, but probably not. So many of the scientists who favor the existence of extraterrestrials are just not buying into the UFO phenomenon. And that should tell you something. As appealing as it sounds to many, after many thousands of reports over decades there is still not a single credible piece of evidence of their existence. And for the conspiracy buffs, I highly doubt that our government would be spending billions of dollars to look for microbes on Mars if they had already made contact with grays from Zeta Reticuli.

Aliens might not be using technology that allows for us to detect them and given the distances, harsh environments and complexity involved with accomplishing such a feat? It could be some time before we hear from our nearest neighbors. Image Credit: NASA

Aliens might not be using technology that allows for us to detect them, and given the distances, harsh environments, and complexity involved with accomplishing such a feat? It could be some time before we hear from our nearest neighbors. Image Credit: NASA

Physicist Paul Davies speculates there made be some great filters at work here, such as life-ending cosmic collisions or self-destructing civilizations limiting the amount of time that they’re around. This could account for, as he puts it, “the eerie silence.” I think the first is improbable. Any advanced civilization would certainly have the technology to obliterate or alter the course of some rogue asteroid or comet heading their way. The second is an interesting concept though. How long do civilizations hang around able to advertise their presence? He uses the example of a town of one hundred people. If over a 24-hour period each homeowner were to turn their lights on for only ten seconds randomly, what would be the odds that two houses would have their lights on at the same time? Not good. However, if you increase the amount of homes or lengthen the time of illumination the chances go up dramatically.

Or maybe it is just as simple as the warning Stephen Hawking has given us. Don’t go looking for something you may not want to find. Maybe there are tons of advanced civilizations out there, but nobody wants to advertise their presence for fear of someone like Darth Vader and the evil empire gobbling them up and spitting them out. Or maybe extraterrestrial intelligence is so advanced we wouldn’t even know it if we saw or heard it. Some scientists theorize advanced alien intelligence would probably be indistinguishable to us from magic.

Andrew Fain has written on other outlets regarding the possibility of alien life. Photo courtesy of the author.

Andrew Fain has written on other outlets regarding the possibility of alien life. Photo courtesy of the author.

So where does that leave us? There could always be that possibility that we are the only game in town in the vast wilderness of our galaxy, but I don’t think so. I think that there are a number of intelligent civilizations out there as we speak. Maybe not as many as we originally thought, but they are out there. We could have already detected their presence (the wow signal) or that moment may be just around the corner. There could also be other reasons for the silence. Reasons we have yet to grasp. The great Carl Sagan once said, “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.”

If and when that moment arrives, the significance to mankind would be profound. God would still be with us, but the result of contact would set our notions of us and our place in the cosmos on a new course. One that would lead to mind boggling scientific discoveries and a new sense of our own existence, not as separate nations and people warring with each other but as one global race and part of something much larger and incredibly more significant.

Andrew Fain

Andrew Fain is a longtime Planetary Society member and resident of Huntington Beach, Calif. He has been writing stories and essays on the possibilities of extraterrestrial life for more than 20 years. He is also a member of the SETI League.

4 comments to Opinion: E.T. Are You Out There?

  • Good summary. However, you missed one point on the Fermi paradox (that otherwise is the best I’ve seen.) His assumption includes no FTL, just sub light. It also could use some clarification that it is not about detection. It’s all about why aren’t they here having a cup of joe.

  • We may have to “settle” for the discovery of microbial life in the near future (which I believe will happen sooner rather than later). Such an inevitable event will have an incredible impact on humanity and will accelerate techological efforts to find other life forms. Intelligent life “out there?” Yes, we’ll discover such evidence in due time – I’m certain of it!

  • Karol

    Excellent article! This subject always raises fascinating issues. As Dr. Stephen Hawkins posited, considering how less technologically developed civilizations often do not fare very well when “visited” by more advanced civilizations, are we sure that we want them to know we’re here? Dr. Neil DeGrasse Tyson asked us when walking outdoors, if we see a worm on the sidewalk, do we wonder what it is thinking? A civilization that is millions of years farther advanced than we are may simply not care to contact us as they would have nothing to gain. It would be interesting to the theological community if an E.T.looking like an eight foot tall squid would earnestly inform us that God made HIM in His own image. How would the most advanced members of the science/technology community on prehistoric Earth who created state-of-the-art stone axes react to the appearance of an outsider with a chain saw? Thanks AmericaSpace for providing a forum where such questions can be freely considered and discussed.

  • […] universe or even in our own galaxy has had no results whatsoever, despite the likelihood of their existence. There has been a few attempts to make mathematical estimates about how many planets similar to our […]