“For One Priceless Moment”: The Walk of Apollo 11

Buzz Aldrin poses with the Stars and Stripes on the Sea of Tranquillity. Photo Credit: NASA

Forty-three years ago, more than three and a half billion people lived on Earth…and three others inhabited an environment far more distant, far more hostile and far more exotic. The Apollo 11 crew were the third team of human explorers to reach the Moon, but whilst Mike Collins remained in orbit, aboard the command module Columbia, his comrades Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin had descended in the lunar module Eagle to the surface itself. Against all the odds, a perfect touchdown on alien soil had been accomplished on the Sea of Tranquillity and the time rapidly approached when they would take the steps which would earn them immortality: the first ‘Moonwalk’.

For the first time in four days, Armstrong and Aldrin could now feel something of their Earthly weight – albeit a mere sixth of it – as lunar gravity took its toll. It enabled Aldrin to celebrate Holy Communion. Opening a personal stowage pouch, given to him by his Presbyterian minister, Reverend Dean Woodruff, he pulled out a tiny wine flask and chalice and a handful of wafers and put all three on Eagle’s small keypad.

“This is the LM Pilot speaking,” he said at 5:57 pm Central Standard Time (CST) on 20 July 1969, some two hours after landing. “I’d like to request a few moments of silence. I’d like to take this opportunity to ask every person listening in, whoever and wherever they may be, to pause for a moment and contemplate the events of the past few hours, and to give thanks in his or her own way.” Upturning the flask, Aldrin watched as the wine curled its way, sluggishly, in one-sixth gravity, into the chalice. In silence, he read from the Book of John: “I am the vine and you are the branches / Whoever remains in me and I in him will bear much fruit / For you can do nothing without me…”

There was much to do. After confirming that Eagle was undamaged, the conservative flight plan called for the astronauts to take a four-hour nap before beginning preparations for the Moonwalk. This was about as likely as telling a child to sleep on Christmas morning. In the weeks before the launch, the idea of skipping this brief sleep period and proceeding directly into ‘EVA Prep’ had been discussed and when Armstrong formally requested it at 5:11 pm CST it did not take long for Capcom Charlie Duke to respond with Mission Control’s full approval.

Neil Armstrong’s departure from Eagle was followed, 16 minutes later, by Buzz Aldrin. Many of the Moonwalkers described the laborious process of backing themselves through the hatch and onto the lunar module’s porch as like being born. Photo Credit: NASA

“Houston, Tranquillity?”

“Go, Tranquillity. Over.”

“Our recommendation,” said Armstrong, “at this point is planning an EVA – with your concurrence – starting about 8 o’clock Houston time. That is about three hours from now.”

“Stand by,” said Duke, turning to Flight Director Gene Kranz.

Notwithstanding the 2.6-second time delay as radio signals crackled back and forth across the 240,000-mile cislunar gulf, Duke’s next words reached the astronauts just nine seconds after Armstrong made his request.

“Tranquillity Base, Houston. We thought about. We will support it.”

Donning of their lunar surface equipment was far more complex than it had been in Earth-bound simulations and was not aided by the fact that Eagle’s tiny cabin was filled with checklists, food packages, stopwatches and other assorted equipment. Armstrong and Aldrin spent an hour preparing their gear, then three hours putting it on: rubber-soled lunar overshoes, backpacks, oxygen hoses, coolant umbilicals, outer helmets, chest-mounted control units and others. In his autobiography, Men from Earth, Aldrin described them as like a pair of fullbacks in a Cub Scout tent, whilst Armstrong told his biographer, James Hansen, that it was “pretty close in there, with the suits inflated”.

After a brief struggle to open Eagle’s hatch, the men were exposed to vacuum as the last vestiges of air rushed out in a flurry of ice crystals. At once, Armstrong clumsily dropped to his knees, his head facing the back of the cabin, his feed inside the yawning square opening that marked the threshold to a dream which had captivated humanity for thousands of years. His backpack extended to some height and he had to move delicately to avoid causing damage. At length, he was on the lunar module’s porch and was reminded by the duty Capcom, Bruce McCandless, to pull a lanyard to deploy a black-and-white television camera to monitor his descent to the surface.

Eerie in its grainy quality and inherent darkness, this segment from the black-and-white film of Neil Armstrong’s descent to the surface is the tangible record of humanity’s first footsteps into the Universe around us. Photo Credit: NASA

The images – replayed so many times – still retain their ghostly, ethereal quality as the first record of our footsteps into the Universe. Armstrong was difficult to see in Eagle’s shadow, but the bright plain of the Sea of Tranquillity and the black sky could be easily discerned. Descending the nine-rung ladder was by no means dizzying and he felt so light that he dropped with the grace of a snowflake down each step and into the footpad. To check his abilities, he sprang back up to the first rung, then returned to the footpad. Glancing around, he told his terrestrial audience what he saw: “The surface,” he began at 9:55:38 pm CST, “appears to be very, very fine-grained as you get close to it. It’s almost like a powder.” Forty seconds later, Neil Armstrong set foot on the Moon.

According to NASA’s official flight transcript, the epochal moment came at 9:56:15 pm CST, when he raised his left boot over Eagle’s footpad and planted it on the lunar soil. Seconds later came the historic words: “That’s one small step for man…one giant leap for mankind.” The origin of the statement has been the subject of much debate over the years, but its significance underlines the value that humanity places in its symbolic gestures, words and deeds. As a pragmatist, Armstrong may not have realised the extent to which the public expected him to utter a profound comment, but even in the modern world people still regard the Moon as an object of wonder, a final resting-place for ancestors and an intensely holy land. Armstrong’s words treated the first steps with dignity, reverence and respect, as the technical journey now faded and the human journey – our species’ first pilgrimage to the lunar surface – took precedence.

In those few steps, he tested his weight and found that he could pick up the soil loosely with his toe; it adhered to the soles and sides of his boots like layered charcoal. The prints imprinted the surface barely a few millimetres, but left clear impressions, and moving around in one-sixth of terrestrial gravity felt entirely natural. (Armstrong’s mother, Viola, watching his steps on television, described him as “buoyant” and “almost floating”; an entirely appropriate choice of words, both figuratively and literally.)

Eagle’s descent engine had left no appreciable crater, although erosive ‘rays’ on the surface illustrated the effect of its impulse, just prior to touchdown. Next came the arrival of the large Hasselblad camera, via the clothesline-like Lunar Equipment Conveyor, and Armstrong became so engrossed in photographing the hinterland of Tranquillity that he almost forgot to collect a contingency sample of soil. It took Aldrin and Bruce McCandless a couple of calls to remind him. Digging the sample was a strange sensation: although the upper layer of the surface was soft, he very quickly ran into a hard, very cohesive material. “It has a stark beauty of its own,” he remarked, “much like the high desert of the United States. It’s different, but it’s very pretty out here.”

Sixteen minutes into the Moonwalk, it was Aldrin’s turn to venture outside and this enabled Armstrong to use the Hasselblad to acquire dramatic images of his crewmate departing Eagle and taking his first steps. As he looked around, two words came to mind: Magnificent desolation. “Nothing prepared me for the starkness of the terrain,” Aldrin recalled later. “It was barren and rolling and the horizon was much closer than I was used to. Earth’s diameter is such that its inhabitants have no personal awareness of the curvature; it’s easy to understand why, for centuries, it was believed to be flat…but on the smaller Moon, my impression was that we were on a ball, or on the knoll of a hill. I even felt a bit disorientated because of the nearness of the horizon.”

Backdropped by the lunar module Eagle, Buzz Aldrin works on the surface. Photo Credit: NASA

As they walked, Armstrong found that the most ‘natural’ gait was a loping motion, in which he alternated feet, pushed off with each step and floated ahead, before planting the next foot. Others included a kind of ‘skipping stride’ and a ‘kangaroo hop’. Although the weight of their backpacks was reduced by five-sixths on the Moon, its effect on their balance meant that they were always slightly pitched forward as they walked; and when Armstrong jumped he felt a tendency to tip over backwards as soon as he landed. They had to take care in turning and halting. “I noticed immediately,” Aldrin recounted in Men from Earth, “that my inertia seemed much greater. Earthbound, I would have stopped my run in just one step…an abrupt halt. I immediately sensed that if I tried this on the Moon, I’d be face-down in the lunar dust. I had to use two or three steps and sort of wind down. The same applied to turning around…on Earth, it’s simple, but on the Moon, it’s done in stages.”

Having assured themselves of a more-or-less solid footing on alien soil, the astronauts’ next task was to unveil a commemorative plaque on the strut of the lander that held the ladder. At 10:24 pm CST, less than half an hour after setting foot on the surface, Armstrong described the plaque to his television audience: Other objects left on the surface included a small silicon disk, bearing statements from Presidents Eisenhower, Kennedy, Johnson and Nixon, together with good tidings from more than 70 other heads of state. Pope Paul VI had quoted the Eighth Psalm and, touchingly, the astronauts left medals and shoulder patches in memory of fallen comrades and adversaries in the exploration of the heavens: Yuri Gagarin, Vladimir Komarov, Gus Grissom, Ed White and Roger Chaffee.

As Apollo 11 was an American venture, and paid for by the American public, but one undertaken in the name ‘of all mankind’, the problem of what kind of flag to plant on the Moon arose frequently in the months before launch. Some felt that the flag of the United Nations was appropriate, but others argued with equal vigour for the Stars and Stripes. At President Nixon’s inauguration six months earlier, he had spoken of going “to new worlds together…not as new worlds to be conquered, but as a new adventure to be shared”. Was he hinting that a United Nations flag should be raised on Apollo 11? Some spectators believed so, and it was perhaps with this in mind that in February 1969 newly appointed NASA Administrator Tom Paine formed a Committee on Symbolic Activities for the First Lunar Landing to determine how one of the most historic events in human history should be marked. The committee heard convincing arguments in favour of a UN flag and in favour of depositing a collection of miniature flags of all nations, but finally it decided that a Stars and Stripes would be erected.

When NASA formally notified members of Congress on 10 June 1969 that it intended to raise the national flag on the Moon, its appropriations bill for the next fiscal year was immediately approved. When the final version of the $3.7 billion bill was agreed by a House and Senate conference committee on 4 November, one provision stated that “the flag of the United States, and no other flag, shall be implanted or otherwise placed on the surface of the Moon, or on the surface of any planet, by the members of the crew of any spacecraft…as part of any mission…the funds of which are provided entirely by the Government of the United States…” It was, indeed, a symbol of national pride.

Neil Armstrong (left) clutches the staff of the Stars and Stripes, whilst Buzz Aldrin works on the flag itself. Photo Credit: NASA

The development of the flag is a long and intriguing story in itself, but the photographs which Armstrong took of Aldrin snapping a smart military salute, against the backdrop of the desolate lunar surface, proved to be some of the most iconic. Yet Armstrong’s absence from most images has been described by James Hansen as “one of the minor tragedies of Apollo 11”. Over the years, outrageous claims have been made that Aldrin ‘intentionally’ avoided taking direct photographs of his commander on the Moon, with some even ludicrously pointing to a perceived bitterness over losing the chance to be first on the surface. In reality, of course, both men were outside Eagle for little more than two hours and virtually every minute of that time was spent on assigned tasks: getting the contingency sample, unveiling the plaque, erecting the flag, deploying a pair of instruments and conducting geological inspections and taking specimens. They were not there to ‘smell the roses’, said Aldrin. Rather, they had a job to do.

Having said this, the primary reason that there were so few images of the First Man was because Armstrong had possession of the Hasselblad for most of the time. “As the sequence of lunar operations evolved,” Aldrin wrote later, “Neil had the camera…and the majority of the pictures taken on the Moon that include an astronaut are of me. It wasn’t until we were back on Earth and in the Lunar Receiving Laboratory, looking over the pictures that we realised there were few pictures of Neil. My fault, perhaps, but we had never simulated this during our training.” For his part, Armstrong cared little about who took pictures of whom, as long as those pictures were good. “I don’t think Buzz had any reason to take my picture,” he told James Hansen, “and it never occurred to me that he should.”

The historic nature of the mission, indeed, made it inevitable that there would be a live telephone conversation with the astronauts’ head of state…and this was the event that both men blamed for their inability to get a good photograph of the First Man. According to Aldrin, seconds after Armstrong had taken the picture of him saluting the Stars and Stripes, Houston came on the line to say that President Nixon wished to talk to them. Apparently, Aldrin explained, the men were just about to swap the Hasselblad at that point, with the intention of taking some images of Armstrong, but were distracted by the request and the subject was later forgotten in the hurry to get everything done.

Very few images exist of Neil Armstrong on the surface; most are underexposed or unposed or reflected in Buzz Aldrin’s visor. This view from a televised transmission shows Armstrong (left) and Aldrin during their Moonwalk. Photo Credit: NASA

None of this, of course, even implies that the failure of either man to suggest taking a posed photograph of Armstrong was anything less than an oversight, and something neither man thought important at the time. “I was intimidated by the enormity of the situation,” Aldrin recalled later. Almost all of the pictures that he did take on the few occasions that he had possession of the Hasselblad were pictures which the flight plan called for him to take. A picture of Neil Armstrong was not on the list. Whatever the reality, at 11:47:47 pm, Bruce McCandless called both men from their respective work.

“We’d like to get both of you in the field of view of the camera for a minute.” McCandless paused for a second, then continued: “Neil and Buzz, the President of the United States is in his office now and would like to say a few words to you. Over.”

“That would be an honour,” replied Armstrong.

“All right. Go ahead, Mr President. This is Houston. Out.”

“Hello, Neil and Buzz,” Nixon began. “I’m talking to you by telephone from the Oval Room at the White House and this certainly has to be the most historic telephone call ever made. I just can’t tell you how proud we all are of what you have done. For every American, this has to be the proudest day of our lives. And for all people all over the world, I am sure they, too, join with Americans in recognising what an immense feat this is. Because of what you have done, the heavens have become a part of man’s world. And as you talk to us from the Sea of Tranquillity, it inspires us to redouble our efforts to bring peace and tranquillity to Earth.”

Then, Nixon added the words which would bring a lump to many a throat and reinforce the reality that the human race had never been as unified as it was now: “For one priceless moment,” he intoned quietly, “in the whole history of man, all the people on this Earth are truly one…one in their pride in what you have done and one in our prayers that you will return safely to Earth.”

Armstrong had been told by Deke Slayton, before launch, that there was a likelihood of some form of ‘special communication’, but it would seem that he had little idea who it might be. Judging from his response to the president – a polite “thank you”, a couple of instances of “it’s an honour” and a brief note about his desire for “peace for all nations” – the brevity of Armstrong’s words would seem to suggest that both men felt unprepared, nervous and decidedly ill at ease. His mother, Viola, could tell from her son’s voice that he was “emotionally shaken” and detected an unmistakable “tremor” in his tone.

Against a haunting backdrop of dark and light, Buzz Aldrin stands close to one of Eagle’s four landing legs. Photo Credit: NASA

With the unveiling of the plaque and the raising of the flag and the words with Nixon now behind them, the astronauts could set to work on the scientific side of their mission. Armstrong’s role during this time would be to collect samples of lunar material. “The geology community had hoped we would provide what they called ‘documented samples’,” he explained to Hansen, “that is, samples whose emplacement was photographed prior to and after lifting the samples. Time did not permit our doing as much of that as we had hoped.” Most of the samples were basalts – a dense, dark-grey-coloured, finely grained igneous rock, composed mainly of calcium-rich plagioclase feldspar and pyroxene – and the oldest of the specimens were later pegged at 3.7 billion years old.

As Armstrong laboured with the samples, it was Aldrin’s responsibility to take the lead in setting up an automated research station on the surface. This Early Apollo Scientific Experiments Package (EASEP) was a forerunner of the more sophisticated Apollo Lunar Surface Experiments Packages which would be deployed by subsequent landing crews. As their time outside drew towards its close, one of the few changes in the plan came when Armstrong took it upon himself to go photograph a yawning bowl-shaped crater about 180 feet east of Eagle which has since become known as ‘East Crater’. To get there as quickly as possible, he adopted a loping, foot-to-foot stride. He took half a dozen Hasselblad images, including outcroppings in the crater. By the time he returned to Eagle, his adventure had lasted a little over three minutes. It was now 11:45 pm CST and Aldrin had been advised that they had only a few minutes left before packing their equipment away.

“There was just far too little time to do the variety of things that we would have liked to have done,” Armstrong explained in the post-flight press conference. “When you are in a new environment, everything around you is different and you have the tendency to look a little more carefully. In a simulation, you just picked up the rock and threw it into the pot!” Similarly, both men had seen rocks through Eagle’s cabin windows before they set foot on the surface – rocks which may have been pieces of lunar bedrock, potentially priceless geological specimens – which they did not have time to inspect, photograph or collect. President Nixon’s telephone call had eaten more time out of their excursion, as had the assembly of the flag and the reading of the plaque.

Photographed during their triumphant tickertape procession through the streets of New York City, the crew’s accomplishment guaranteed them eternal fame and changed their lives forever. Photo Credit: NASA

As Aldrin headed up the ladder at 11:56 pm CST, Armstrong sealed the last rock box. Then, working together, the two men hauled the film magazines, the Hasselblad and the two rock boxes into Eagle. At 12:09 am on 21 July, the First Man on the Moon jumped with both feet into Eagle’s footpad and set his gloved hands on the ladder; after a little more than two full hours, this was his last direct contact with lunar soil. He then crouched into a kind of deep-knee bend, getting his torso as close to the footpad as possible…and sprang himself upwards, easily reaching the third rung. Two minutes later, he was back inside Eagle and Aldrin had pushed shut and sealed the hatch. All in all, the world’s first excursion on alien soil had lasted two hours and 31 minutes from depressurisation to repressurisation of the cabin, of which Armstrong had actually been on the surface for two hours and 14 minutes and Aldrin for one hour and 46 minutes.

After an uncomfortable night’s sleep, the two men left the Moon at 12:53 pm, a little more than 21 hours since landing, and their ascent into lunar orbit and rendezvous with a happy Mike Collins aboard Columbia was charmed. Aldrin’s words to Collins as he passed the sample containers through the tunnel – “Get ready for these million-dollar boxes” – was entirely appropriate; for not only were the specimens of the Sea of Tranquillity now priceless, but so too were the men themselves. From the moment the scorched and blackened cone of Columbia descended through the clouds and splashed into the Pacific Ocean on 24 July 1969, the names of Neil Armstrong, Mike Collins and Buzz Aldrin would gain immortal status and their lives would never be the same again.

 

This is part of a series of History articles which will appear each weekend, barring any major news stories. Next week’s article will focus on Apollo 15, a mission which carried humanity’s exploration of the Moon into the mysterious mountains of Hadley-Apennine.

Missions » Apollo »

3 comments to “For One Priceless Moment”: The Walk of Apollo 11

  • Karol

    I’m sure that you’re probably tired of reading this from me Ben, but I greatly appreciate and enjoy your exceptionally well-written articles. To say that you are a gifted writer with an amazing, unparalleled wealth of knowledge about space exploration would most certainly be to damn by faint praise. As to your most recent work, I have a question that only Ben Evans could definitively answer. Is it true Ben that when Armstrong and Aldrin re-entered the cramped lunar module wearing their cumbersome, ungainly EVA suits, one of the backpacks hit the toggle switch to arm the ascent engine, breaking it off below the level of the instrument panel, and that a ballpoint pen had to be used to throw the toggle switch. Having viewed the eerie, chilling prerecorded speech prepared by President Nixon to be used in the event of a tragic event on the Moon, that they came in peace for all mankind, and fate has decreed that they rest in peace on the surface of the Moon, I wondered if the toggle switch incident was true, or just an old spacers tale oft told around the campfire. Again, thanks so much Ben for your great work!

  • Steve

    It is true. I have seen it documented in several autobiographical and space history books.

  • Ben Evans

    Karol, Steve is right. Buzz Aldrin made reference to it in ‘Men From Earth’, but described it as a felt-tipped pen used to plug the gap for the ascent engine’s arming circuit breaker. Thanks for your comment.